Review fixes for Phase 7 Wave D.
#1 (HIGH): STATUS_DIR_TIMES entries no longer create directories. A new
receiver-only File.dir_time_only flag marks dir-time entries; file_save_to_disk_full
short-circuits them as FILE_SAVE_SKIPPED before any device/dir branch, so the sink
still accumulates metadata into the deferred DirTimeList but creates nothing. Empty
source dirs stay untransferred (-a), -m/--prune-empty-dirs semantics are preserved,
and a pre-existing regular file/symlink at an empty-dir mirror path no longer aborts
the transfer. dir_time_list_apply fstatat()s the leaf (AT_SYMLINK_NOFOLLOW) and skips
absent/non-directory paths QUIETLY; only a real existing directory is stamped.
Also initialize File.dir_time_only in file_create() (uninitialised garbage otherwise).
#2 (MED): send_dir_times() chunks entries into repeated STATUS_DIR_TIMES frames of at
most MAX_MANIFEST_ENTRIES, matching the receiver's per-frame bound; the tautological
> INT_MAX check is gone.
#3 (LOW): dir_time_list_add() assigns each grown array right after its realloc (no
dangling) and advances capacity only after both succeed.
#4 (LOW): RSYNC_COMPAT.md -- STATUS_MKDIR carries metadata, dir times are transmitted
via STATUS_DIR_TIMES and applied at the end, empty dirs are still never created; -m
rationale, -O row and Wave D notes updated. Summary counts untouched.
#5 (LOW): integration tests for the three #1 scenarios (empty-dir non-creation under
-a and -a -m, collision non-abort), scanner test now covers empty-dir capture, and
test_file_restore_symlink_metadata asserts the positive apply path when supported.
PROTOCOL_VERSION stays 2.17.0; config-frame layout unchanged.
Wave D of Phase 7. Make -O/--omit-dir-times and -J/--omit-link-times real by
preserving directory and symlink times, and mark --secluded-args as an explicit
Impossible/Divergence no-op.
Wire: PROTOCOL_VERSION 2.16.0 -> 2.17.0. Adds a terminal STATUS_DIR_TIMES frame
(int count + (wire path, metadata) pairs) sent after all file data and the
optional delete manifest. STATUS_MKDIR also carries metadata for --dirs entries.
Config-frame layout is unchanged.
Sender: the recursive scanner captures every traversed source directory (both
DirectoryScanner and the parallel scanner root + workers, appends mutex-guarded)
into a shared list; the single-threaded and -m paths transmit it last.
Receiver: a DirTimeList accumulates received directory metadata and applies it
with fd-relative no-follow utimensat only at the very end -- after all children,
after the commit-style --delete, and after --delay-updates publication -- in the
single-threaded success frame and in server.c after the -m threads join. -O skips
the application. Symlink metadata is applied at link creation with
utimensat/fchownat/fchmodat AT_SYMLINK_NOFOLLOW; -J suppresses only link times.
identity_apply_ownership_link shares the identity resolver with the fd path.
Docs: -O/-J rows -> Implemented; --secluded-args -> Impossible/Divergence;
--protocol accepted/rejected values and Phase-6/7 notes updated.
Tests: unit (scanner dir capture, DirTimeList apply, symlink metadata, protocol
version values) and integration (dir mtime round-trip + -O, symlink mtime
round-trip + -J, independent suppression), parameterized over single/multithread.
Source files sharing (st_dev,st_ino) are recreated as hard links on the
destination; only the first member's data crosses the wire (siblings ride a
payload-less STATUS_HARDLINK frame). Ordering requires the single-FIFO-writer
receiver + forced sequential scan (documented). link()-failure falls back to a
byte-identical local copy. Rejects -s/--append. PROTOCOL_VERSION 2.11.0->2.12.0.
Review fixes: delete the dead HardLinkRegistry (ordering holds by FIFO writer),
and --existing no longer aborts when the first member is absent but the sibling
exists (leaves the sibling in place).
PROTOCOL_VERSION 2.9.0 -> 2.10.0. The STATUS_MANIFEST frame gains a third
section carrying destination-relative exact-delete paths (the missing
--files-from entries' mirrors); the config frame gains a delete_missing_args
bool (ignore_missing_args stays client-only). The receiver validates the third
section like the keep-set and commits it with manifest_delete_all():
manifest_delete_missing_args runs first (explicit user requests, never blocked
by protected-prefix exclusion protection; staging/basis protected; a non-empty
directory mirror removed only under --force/--delete, rsync parity) and then the
ordinary extras walk. Server --allow-delete gates it like --delete.
The STATUS_MANIFEST frame now carries two count-delimited sections: the kept
paths and a protected-prefix list (excluded-on-source paths the walker must not
delete unless --delete-excluded opted out). The receiver's DeleteManifest is
passed through the commit/early paths unchanged. manifest_delete_extras
honors a client --max-delete (all-or-nothing) and produces a distinct error for
it versus the 100000-entry server bound. --force clears a non-empty directory
that blocks an incoming regular file (confined, symlink-safe) via a new
file_remove_tree_secure helper.
The late/commit path keeps the received keep-set in a local list until
STATUS_FINISHED. Error exits after it was parked (STATUS_ABORT, a failing
receive_status / non-FINISHED status, a second manifest frame, or a later
file/chunk/store failure) previously dropped the only reference and leaked up
to ~16 MB of path strings + pointer array per connection. Both failure labels
now discard the parked list exactly once; the successful FINISHED path still
hands ownership to *pending_manifest (the -m caller) without freeing it.
Deletion timing is now real and selected by the four rsync flags plus the
plain --delete default. Wire protocol bumps to 2.8.0: two new config
booleans (delete_during, delete_delay) are serialized and validated, joining
the existing delete_before/delete_after.
- Early modes (--delete-before, --delete-during/--del): the sender pre-scans
the whole tree (paths only), transmits the keep-set manifest BEFORE any
file data, and the receiver removes extras and acks STATUS_OK; the sender
only streams data after the deletion committed. Deletion is thus performed
even if a later transfer phase fails (rsync delete-before/during are
destructive by definition). FastSync streams in a single scan so it cannot
interleave per-directory like rsync delete-during; --delete-during selects
the same engine mode as --delete-before (documented divergence).
- Late/commit modes (plain --delete, --delete-after, --delete-delay): the
manifest closes the data stream and deletion is committed only after
STATUS_FINISHED proves the whole transfer succeeded, preserving FastSync's
commit-style safety. --delete-delay converges with --delete-after because
FastSync never snapshots the destination during data flow (documented).
- The STATUS_MANIFEST frame is now self-delimiting and position-independent.
Single-threaded receivers delete before the success frame; the -m receiver
hands the keep-set to server.c, which commits the deletion only after the
disk writer thread has drained (fixes a delete-vs-in-flight-temp race).
- Every timing flag implies --delete; at most one timing flag is allowed.
- Each timing flag implies --delete, matching rsync; conflicts are rejected.
The receiver's per-file incremental check now consults the ordered basis-dir
list whenever the destination is not already up to date. An exact basis match
requires equal size, equal mtime (unless --size-only; --ignore-times disables
basis matching like rsync), and an equal content xxHash64 -- the sender sends
its xxHash for every file whenever basis dirs are configured (not only under
--checksum), so a hard link or local copy is only ever made from byte-identical
content.
On a match:
- compare-dest: reply STATUS_OK and skip data only when the destination does
not already hold the file (sparse, rsync parity). A destination that holds
a DIFFERENT version falls back to a normal transfer instead of rsync's
delete, keeping the mirror complete.
- copy-dest: reply STATUS_OK and hand a synthetic File (bytes read from the
basis file, basis metadata) to the normal store sink, so the file is
installed as a real local copy through the existing atomic temp+rename
engine and honors --existing/--ignore-existing/--update/--backup/
--delay-updates/--partial-dir unchanged.
- link-dest: same, but File.basis_link records the basis path and the store
engine calls the new file_to_disk_secure_link(): an atomic temp hard link +
rename. Cross-filesystem/refused links fall back to a byte-identical local
copy (never a corrupt or partial file); the copy fallback applies metadata,
while a successful link keeps the basis inode's own attributes so the basis
file is never mutated.
Basis-materialized files carry File.skip so they are not acknowledged to a
--remove-source-files sender (the sender already saw STATUS_OK and keeps the
source). The no-match path is byte-for-byte identical to the existing delta /
full-data transfer.
RSYNC_COMPAT Phase-2 row M: path-list construction and destination
directory creation while preserving traversal safety.
- -R/--relative with --files-from: transmit each listed entry under its
bare relative destination path (no source-root mirror). Files keep an
absolute local read path plus a separate wire/dest path (File.send_path);
manifest, incremental quick-check and change output follow the wire path,
so --delete and --remove-source-files stay consistent. -R without
--files-from is unchanged (full mirror).
- --no-implied-dirs: client-only, only meaningful with -R + --files-from.
A listed file whose parent dir is not itself (or via an ancestor)
explicitly listed cannot be placed; the run fails up front with a clear
error. No effect otherwise.
- --dirs/-d + --old-dirs/--old-d aliases: -d <dir> transmits the source
root as an explicit empty directory entry (STATUS_MKDIR frame); with
--files-from listed dirs are created empty and listed files transferred,
never descending. Works single-threaded, -m (sequential scanner in the
-m scan thread) and chunk-serialization (per-file type marker).
Directory entries appear in the delete manifest.
- --mkpath: new wire bool; server creates the destination root (and missing
leading components under its authorized root) at connection start. A
missing destination root is now rejected by default.
- Protocol bumped to 2.7.0 (mkpath wire field + STATUS_MKDIR + chunk type
marker). All receive paths funnel through file_save_to_disk_full which
creates directories via the secure confined mkdir engine; dir entries are
excluded from --remove-source-files outcome acknowledgements on both ends.
- Unit coverage: CLI parse (relative/dirs aliases/mkpath/no-implied-dirs),
config round-trip (relative + mkpath), scanner --dirs non-recursion and
-R send_path (sequential + parallel), receiver dir-entry save.
- Integration coverage: TestRelativeFilesFrom, TestNoImpliedDirs, TestDirs,
TestMkpath (single and -m).
- RSYNC_COMPAT: 4 rows move to Implemented (Summary 67/3/5/1/71 = 147).
Stage every successfully written file under a private 0700 .fastsync-stage
directory inside the receive root and atomically publish all staged files
only after the whole protocol stream (manifest/delete handling included)
has completed, immediately before the success/outcome frame. On any
abort/error before publication nothing is installed and staging is removed;
a publish failure aborts the transfer with best-effort cleanup of the
remainder (already-published files are not rolled back). Crash leftovers
are wiped when the next delayed transfer starts.
Wire: new delay_updates config flag (selection-options block), protocol
version bumped to 2.6.0, client/server validation rejects --inplace.
CLI/usage/validation updated. Works in single-threaded and -m modes
(exactly one write_thread stages files; the staged-file registry is
mutex-protected; publication runs once after both threads join).
--existing/--ignore-existing/--update decide against the final destination
at stage time; --backup is deferred to publication. remove_source_files
outcomes are only sent after publication so skipped/unpublished sources are
never deleted. Default (no flag) behavior is unchanged.
Tests: config wire round-trip, CLI parse, --inplace rejection, new
test_delay_updates unit suite (27 suites total), and integration
TestDelayUpdates covering single/-m parity, incremental reruns, remove
source files, receiver-skip ordering, and a deterministic publish-failure
abort path.
#251 --remove-source-files deletes sources that were skipped receiver-side
(--existing/--ignore-existing/--update). The receiver now reports a
per-file outcome for every processed data file when the sender requests
removal; the client only unlinks sources the receiver actually wrote.
add remove_source_files to the wire config and bump the protocol to 2.5.0.
#252 --backup/--suffix/--backup-dir broken by NULL-vs-empty wire loss. Receivers
canonicalize the empty wire string back to NULL for backup_dir, temp_dir,
partial_dir and suffix, and --suffix is received unconditionally.
#253 --partial --partial-dir never installed completed files. file_save_to_disk
now renames a fully written partial-dir file into the real destination.
#255 STATUS_CHECK read the entire old file before the size/mtime quick check.
Old contents are only read when a checksum compare or delta needs them.
#256 receive_delta_file failure paths did not set *failed, so the caller sent
STATUS_NEXT and waited for a body that never came. Every NULL return now
marks the transfer failed.
#257 files >64 MiB could not transfer. Whole-file receive caps raised to the
256 MiB connection/allocation ceiling (chunk caps stay 64 MiB) and the
client ignores SIGPIPE so a server-side close surfaces as a clean error.
Unit tests added: config NULL-vs-empty round trip, incremental quick-check
skip/NEXT paths, delta oversize failure, partial-dir install, save-result
skip reporting.
The Phase 1 merge conflict resolutions introduced formatting that failed
the CI lint job (clang-format 18.1.3). Reformatted with the exact CI
version; no functional changes.
TapTap